Purina Pro Plan vs Blue Buffalo

How well do you know your favorite pet food brand? The pet food market offers a wide variety of products from which to choose. While variety and unlimited options are a good thing for consumers, sometimes knowing which brand is best can be challenging. When it comes to pet food, quality ingredients are one of the considerations you should keep in mind when shopping. However, with all brands posing as the best on the market, how do you make the distinction?

Purina Pro Plan and Blue Buffalo are both very popular brands and we are going to compare the two.

Protein

Purina Pro Plan dry food products typically contain 3.28 more grams of protein than Blue Buffalo. In the wet food category, Purina Pro Plan has 6.86 more grams of protein content than Blue Buffalo. In terms of protein content Purina Pro Plan is the superior brand with higher protein content across all categories.

Cost

Blue Buffalo is more costly than Purina Pro Plan, though in the wet food category, Purina Pro products cost more. On the whole, both Purina Pro Plan and Blue Buffalo are on the affordable end of the spectrum and both are great options for quality and budget-friendly brands.

Variety

Blue Buffalo has a wide range of flavors with 339 different options from which to choose, while Purina Pro Plan has 165 flavor options. Blue Buffalo is, therefore, the superior brand when it comes to product range with almost double the number of flavors that Purina Pro Plan has to offer. If you are enjoying this article, check out our article on the best dog food for miniature schnauzer.

Nutritional Value

In terms of nutrient content, Purina Pro Plan contains a higher protein content than Blue Buffalo across all the different food types, but in terms of fat and fiber, they are relatively close.

Dry Dog Food

Purina Pro Plan

Blue Buffalo

Crude Protein

31%

28%

Crude Fat

17%

15%

Crude Fiber

4%

7%


 Wet Dog Food

 

Crude Protein

47%

41%

Crude Fat

16%

21%

Crude Fiber

7%

6%

 

 

Dry Cat Food

Purina Pro Plan

Blue Buffalo

Crude Protein

45%

37%

Crude Fat

17%

16%

Crude Fiber

3%

6%


 Wet Cat Food

 

Crude Protein

51%

45%

Crude Fat

17%

24%

Crude Fiber

6%

6%

Ingredients And Flavor

Purina Pro Plan has built a reputation as a premium brand with high-quality pet foods made from wholesome, natural ingredients including chicken, rice, turkey, salmon, soybean, corn syrup, whole grain corn, whole grain wheat, and poultry by-products.

The most popular flavors of Purina Pro Plan products are

  • Chunky chicken
  • Turkey and cheese
  • HA hydrolyzed formula chicken flavor
  • Salmon and ocean fish

Blue Buffalo pet foods are made from nutrient-rich ingredients to deliver healthy recipes in a wide variety of flavors. Blue Buffalo products contain ingredients such as meat, LifeSource bits from fruits and vegetables, pumpkin, peas, pea protein, digestible carbohydrates, canola oil, dried tomato pomace, and essential minerals.

The most popular flavors of Blue Buffalo dog food products include

  • Shepherd’s pie
  • Chicken and trout in gravy
  • Chicken wild bites for dogs
  • Chicken and cheddar

Origin and Manufacturing

The Blue Buffalo headquarters are located in Wilton, Connecticut. It has manufacturing plants in different states and other countries including Canada, Mexico, and Japan. This brand has five different product lines that are all designed to provide for your canine’s nutritional requirements and to meet different dietary needs.

Purina Pro Plan is part of Nestle Purina PetCare. Purina Pro Plan has made its name as a brand that specializes in niche pet products and has four product lines: Savor, Focus, Sport, and Bright Mind. 

Purina Pro Plan Vs Blue Buffalo – Which is the best option?

Purina Pro Plan Strengths:

  • Protein-rich pet foods ideal for active canines and large breeds
  • Affordable and high-quality pet food products
  • Active probiotics to promote gut health
  • Grain-free products ideal for pets with grain sensitivities

Purina Pro Plan Concerns:

  • Tend to contain artificial coloring agents

Blue Buffalo Strengths

  • One of the best options for growing cats and dogs
  • Rich in antioxidants which provide an immunity boost
  • Gluten-free
  • Best option for large breeds and active dogs

Blue Buffalo Concerns:

  • Contain grains which may pose a problem to hypersensitive canines
  • More expensive than Purina Pro Plan pet foods
  • Not recommended for obese or overweight canines

Summary

Purina Pro Plan as a brand has a great safety record. In terms of nutritional content, it comes with more protein than Blue Buffalo products and is more affordable. In essence, while both brands are high-quality pet food manufacturers, Purina Pro Plan is superior to Blue Buffalo in terms of nutrient content, safety record and cost.

Shelly

Hello, I'm Shelly! I write about all things dogs. I'm a proud mother of 3. So I guess my official title is fulltime mother, part-time dog blogger. Look around and if you have any questions reach out to me shelly@mylargedogs.com